A report once stated that over 40,000 electric bicycles were stolen in Hangzhou each year. How can one prevent theft? This question is often on the minds of many people after purchasing a bicycle. The common practice is to buy a U-shaped lock, attach it to the wheel, and assume that everything is safe. Manufacturers have also put in some effort, designing features like handlebar locks, motor locks, and alarms to provide peace of mind.
So, among all these anti-theft measures, which one is more effective? Words alone are not enough to prove anything, so Curious Lab recently asked a professional locksmith to test which locks are truly secure.
Electric vehicle theft is difficult to prevent
The location is the parking area at the entrance of shopping malls and supermarkets
Officer Jin Hejia of the Caihe Police Station in Jianggan District, Hangzhou, has done statistics and found that the highest incidence of electric bicycle thefts occurs in the afternoon, in shopping malls, supermarkets and other electric vehicle parking areas. Although these places are densely populated, they have high mobility and a noisy environment, making it difficult for thieves to be discovered.
Another dangerous time is at night, in residential areas. After getting home from get off work, people park their electric bicycles at the entrance of the building or in the carport to charge. These places are often dimly lit, creating conditions for thieves to commit crimes.
Officer Jin said that judging from the modus operandi, there are three common types:
"The most common method is lock picking, which involves using screwdrivers or homemade iron tools to violently break the lock. Another method involves using hydraulic pliers. If the lock isn't very good, they'll snap it instantly, allowing the car to be stolen. The fastest method is the 'hauling method': two or three people in a small truck or van, when the opportunity presents itself, will simply load any type of lock onto the truck, haul it away, and then return home to investigate."
Tested four types of locks
Nothing is as good as nothing in the face of violence
Simple electric scooters on the market don't have any built-in anti-theft devices, requiring owners to purchase a separate lock. Just how effective is a lock in preventing theft? The program team randomly purchased four common locks, both expensive and inexpensive, from a hardware store. They then had technician Lai Xiwang of Hangzhou Baoling Locksmith try his hand at opening each of them at the fastest possible speed, measuring how long it takes to open them.
result--
Lock Type Price Time Consumption
Single key wire lock 5 yuan 19 seconds
Cross key wire lock 12 yuan 47 seconds
U-shaped lock with single key 12 yuan 27 seconds
Screw key U-shaped lock 68 yuan 2 minutes did not open
"When it comes to technical unlocking, locks with straight keys are simple to open with a single insertion. Those with spiral keys require specialized tools and are impractical. If a thief hasn't succeeded after this long, it's probably time to give up," said Master Lai. However, even the strongest locks have weaknesses. Master Lai explained that these U-shaped locks, while sturdy on the outside, actually have fragile locking points that can pop open with a single strike of a hammer. Sure enough, with a few "bangs," the U-shaped lock with the spiral key was opened in just 20 seconds. Master Lai then used hydraulic pliers and wire cutters to force the locks open. The wire lock with the straight key was the fastest, being cut in 10 seconds. The U-shaped lock with the straight key was the most difficult, but it didn't last more than 25 seconds.
The built-in handlebar lock is unreliable, and the motor lock is technically difficult to unlock. Typically, some luxury e-bikes come with a handlebar lock, motor lock, or other features. The handlebar lock is a mechanical device with a latch inside the handlebar that locks it shut, preventing the handlebar from turning. If you push the bike, it will just spin in place. It's simple to use: turn the handlebar all the way to the left and remove the key.
Master Lai explained that the faucet lock is similar to a car lock, and most locksmiths are familiar with the technique, so it's not very difficult to open. Sure enough, Master Lai successfully opened the faucet lock on an electric bicycle in 56 seconds.
The other type is called a motor lock, which is usually located next to the rear wheel motor. Once locked, the rear wheel cannot rotate.
This time, Master Lai was defeated. After spending a full five minutes, he still couldn't open the motor lock. "The internal structure of the motor lock is different from that of ordinary locks. The lock picking tools I have are completely useless," Master Lai said.
Zhang Fangyong, an engineer at the Lvyuan Electric Vehicle R&D Center, explained that motor locks, also known as magnetic code locks, are characterized by a unique magnetic code on both the key and the lock itself. Each lock has a unique code. Only when both codes match can the lock be opened, making it difficult to open with a pick.
The problem is that if the electric bicycle does not have a motor lock installed before leaving the factory, it will be difficult to install it later.
What if all the above locks are broken through and the car is stolen? Lvyuan Electric Vehicles also has its own Lvdong Network. If the car is moved, the owner can receive a notification in advance. In addition, Lvyuan Electric Vehicles has come up with a solution: installing GPS.
"Install a GPS device in a hidden location on the vehicle, use a computer or mobile phone to locate it, monitor the vehicle's driving trajectory in real time, and then retrieve the vehicle." Engineer Zhang Fangyong said that the GPS anti-theft function of electric bicycles has now entered the testing stage and will soon be assembled and released.